BACKGROUND
History demonstrates a compelling connection
between hate speech and mass atrocity.
ATROCITY SPEECH LAW
(Oxford University Press, 2017)
History demonstrates a compelling connection
between hate speech and mass atrocity.
1991-1962 BC
205-149 BC
1088
1885
1913
1923-1945
1926-1945
1931-1945
1938-1945
ENVER PASHA
Active years: 1913-1918 AD
Enver Pasha was a military officer in the Ottoman Empire who rose to power through the ranks of the political party known as the Committee of Union and Progress (CUP), a faction of the “Young Turk” movement.
A rabid Turkish nationalist and Germanophile, he became part of a leadership triumvirate known as the “three Pashas” (the other two being Talaat and Cemal), who seized power in 1913, the year before World War I started, and lost it in 1918, the year the war ended. Beginning in 1915, the triumvirate attempted to liquidate the Armenian population then living in the Ottoman Empire.
Historian Rouben Paul Adalian describes Enver as "an instigator of the Armenian Genocide." (Encyclopedia on the Armenian Genocide) . He “took the first steps to implement the CUP blueprint for genocide by ordering [the summary execution] of Armenian recruits in the Ottoman forces [which escalated into] a campaign for extermination . . . against the civilian population.” He sent orders down the chain of command to “mobile killer units [that] carried out the systematic massacres of . . . deported Armenians.”
A post-war tribunal in Constantinople tried him in absentia and condemned him to death for these crimes. But he escaped justice, having first fled to Germany and then to the Soviet Union where, in 1922, he was killed in combat while trying to foment a pan-Turkic uprising against the Bolshevik government.
KinG Leopold ii of Belgium
1885-1908 AD
Leopold was the second King of the Belgians from 1865 to 1909 and, via his private initiative, the owner and absolute ruler of the “Congo Free State” from 1885 to 1908. He used Catholic missionaries to help perpetrate a reign of terror in his personally controlled colony. Native Congolese were essentially enslaved by Leopold’s agents to harvest rubber from wild trees.
Georges Nzongola-Ntalaja notes that this resulted in “the depopulation of entire villages and the heinous perpetration of crimes against humanity . . .”
Complicit in these crimes were the Belgian missionaries, who helped subjugate the population on Leopold’s behalf. Adam Hochschild explains that “Leopold subsidized the Catholics lavishly and sometimes used his financial power to deploy priests, almost as if they were soldiers, to areas where he wanted to strengthen his influence.”
Kathryn Rountree adds that Leopold “used the Catholic missions to cement and extend his power in the Congo.” And he used hate speech to indoctrinate these agents before sending them to do his bidding in the colony. In one letter to them, he declaimed:
"Your principal objective in our mission in the Congo is never to teach the niggers to know God …. Your essential role is to … protect your interests in that part of the world. For these things, you have to keep watch on disinteresting our savages from the richness that is plenty …. Evangelize the niggers so that they stay forever in submission to the white colonialists …. Convert always the blacks by using the whip. Keep their women in nine months of submission to work freely for us. Institute a confessional system, which allows you to be good detectives denouncing any black that has a different consciousness contrary to that of the decision-maker. Teach the n****rs to forget their heroes and to adore only ours."
Pope Urban II
1088-1099 AD
Odo of Châtillon served as Pope Urban II from March 1088 until his death in July 1099.
In a sermon given at Clermont in 1095, he called for Christians to go on Crusade, in other words, to seize the Holy Land from the Islamic Seljuk Turks.
He provoked the commission of atrocities by telling them that Muslims "had ravaged the churches of God in the Eastern provinces, circumcised Christian men, violated women, and carried out the most unspeakable torture before killing them."
A contingent of some 12,000 Christian combatants reached Jerusalem on June 7, 1099, defeating the Muslim forces holding the city and then massacring nonbelievers.
As described by historians: "Few would dispute that the Crusades involved war crimes on a massive scale, a whipping-up of religious hatred [that led to the murder of] Jews and Muslims in such numbers that the streets of Jerusalem ran ankle-deep with blood." The Times of London, ( October 27, 2001).
Cato the Elder
Active years: 205-149 BC
Marcus Porcius Cato, known as "Cato the Elder" (to distinguish him from his famous grandson who later became a high-profile opponent of Julius Caesar) was a second century BCE Roman statesman, orator and writer.
He repeatedly, and explicitly, called for the destruction of Carthage (“Carthago delenda est!”). Following these exhortations, Carthage was indeed destroyed with approximately 150,000 out of 200,000 Carthaginians massacred by the Romans: proverbially, the Romans covered the ruins of Carthage with salt to prevent anything from ever growing.
The survivors, 25,000 of whom were women, were sold into slavery. Roman historian Plutarch concluded: “The annihilation of Carthage … was primarily due to the advice and counsel of Cato." (A.E. Astin, Scipio Aemilianus 36 (1967)). Ben Kiernan refers to Cato’s grisly injunctions as possibly "the first recorded incitement to genocide.” (Ben Kiernan, The First Genocide: Carthage, 146 BC, 203 Diogenes 27 (2004)).”
Amenemhet I
Active years: 1991-1962 BC
Egyptian Pharaoh Amenemhet I was the founder of the 12th Dynasty (1991-1802 BCE), considered to be the golden age of Ancient Egypt’s Middle Kingdom.
He is recorded as having incited against other ethnic groups in his region, whom he would ultimately slaughter and enslave, dehumanizing them by referring to them as animals.
Ancient scrolls have him boasting:
Julius Streicher
Founder and Editor-in-Chief of the virulently antisemitic newspaper
Der Stürmer
(1923-1945) and Gauleiter of Franconia (1929-1940)
Julius Streicher was born on February 12, 1885, in the Upper Bavarian village of Fleinhausen. Having served with distinction as a soldier in World War I, he became the leader of the “German Socialist Party” and was initially a rival of Hitler. But given their ideological affinities, they joined forces and Streicher became a loyal Hitler lieutenant. Streicher soon amassed much power, becoming, in rapid succession, a general in the SA Storm Troopers, the Gauleiter (district leader) of Franconia, and a member of the Reichstag.
On his own initiative, he also founded a viciously anti-Jewish newspaper in 1923 called Der Stürmer. Read by 600,000 subscribers at its peak, this crude rag published a constant stream of hate screeds and grotesque caricatures meant to vilify and dehumanize Jews. Displayed on public bulletin boards in glass-covered cases, the publication exerted a significant influence on German attitudes toward the Jewish community.
Julius Streicher Speech
Julius Streicher Speech. Source video uploaded to the Holocaust Encyclopedia, part of the United State Holocaust Memorial Museum.
Reichstag Speech
Reichstag Speech. Source video uploaded to The United States Holocaust Memorial Museum.
Joseph Goebbels
Reichminister for Propaganda (1933-1945)
and Gauleiter for Berlin
The fourth of six children, Paul Joseph Goebbels (who went by Joseph) was born into a Catholic, working-class family in Rheydt, Germany (near Düsseldorf), in 1897. He suffered from poor health during his childhood, developing deep-seated insecurities exacerbated by a deformed right foot and a shortened leg. Rejected for military service during World War I, he earned a Ph.D. in German literature from the University of Heidelberg and began working as a journalist. But in 1924, after seeing Hitler speak, he was drawn to the Nazi party and became a devoted servant to its leader.
Goebbels was put to work on propaganda activities, including editing the Party’s weekly newspaper, Der Angriff, and building up support for Hitler in Berlin (where he became district Party leader and later enacted anti-Jewish discriminatory measures). After the Nazis ascended to power in 1933, Goebbels was appointed Minister for Public Enlightenment and Propaganda with power over the radio, press, publishing, cinema and the other arts.
Through the balance of the 1930s, he was able to “Nazify” German culture by subjecting artists and journalists to strict state control and eliminating all Jews and political opponents from positions of influence.
In the process, Goebbels ordered the burning of “un-German” books and had their authors “blacklisted.” And he reinforced the ideology of Nazi racial superiority through films such as Triumph of the Will, Leni Riefenstahl’s documentary on the Party’s 1934 Nuremberg rally) and Olympia (another Riefenstahl agit-prop piece glorifying Aryan superiority via a stilted depiction of the 1936 Berlin Summer Olympics). Having created an atmosphere of racial fanaticism and antisemitic hatred, Goebbels used a Jewish student’s assassination of a Nazi diplomat in Paris as a pretext to launch a November 9-10 pogrom against German Jews. In what came to be known as “Kristallnacht” (for the smashing of the windows of Jewish homes and businesses), thousands of Jews in the Third Reich were murdered or sent to concentration camps, while synagogues across the country were looted and burned.
In the meantime, Goebbels continued to ramp up his genocidal propaganda against the Jews, delivering his own speeches and producing rabidly antisemitic films, such as Der ewige Jude ( The Eternal Jew – depicting Jews as sub-human), Jud Süß ( Süss the Jew – the account of a Jewish ducal advisor manipulating his employer behind the scenes), and Die Rothschilds (The Rothschilds – a negative depiction of the famous Jewish banking family) (all from 1940). After the September 1939 Nazi invasion of Poland, Goebbels used the full panoply of multimedia and oratory to rouse the German people to arms and, by 1942, to carry out the “Final Solution” – the Nazi plan for the genocide of Europe’s Jews. In a June 1942 address, Goebbels explicitly threatened to carry out the “mass extermination of Jews in reprisal for the Allied air bombings.” The following year, on February 18, 1943, not long after the German surrender at Stalingrad and as Allied bombing of the Third Reich was intensifying, Goebbels delivered his infamous Totaler Krieg ( Total War) address at Berlin’s Sportpalast. Speaking in the fanatical style of Hitler (as was his wont), he sought to persuade the German people not to “bow to the to the Jewish threat” but to “eliminate” it and to fight to the death. The next year, Goebbels was appointed Reich Plenipotentiary for Total War, giving him complete control over the war economy. And he remained by Hitler’s side in the “Führer Bunker” to the bitter end, replacing the dictator as German Chancellor for one day (April 30, 1945), after Hitler had killed himself that morning. On May 1, 1945, Goebbels and his family committed suicide and the Nazi propaganda master managed to escape Allied justice.
Otto Dietrich
Nazi Party Press Chief (1931-1945), Vice-President of the Reich
Press Chamber (1933-1945), and Reich Press Chief (1937-1945)
Born in 1897 in the western German city of Essen, Dietrich served in the German Army during the First World War, and earned the Iron Cross, First Class. In 1921, he was awarded a political science doctorate.
From there, he began a career in the newspaper business. His first position was deputy editor of the Essen Nationalzeitung. The Augsburger Zeitung, a German-national evening paper, then hired him as its business manager.
After marrying the daughter of a wealthy newspaper magnate (owner of the influential Rheinisch-Westfälische Zeitung ), Dietrich became more prominent. His father-in-law introduced him to important Rhineland industrialists and, after joining the Nazi party in 1929, he gave Hitler access to them.
Hitler was appreciative and reciprocated by naming Dietrich the Nazi party press chief. After Hitler became chancellor in 1933, he ultimately placed Dietrich in the same role for the German state. As Press Chief, Dietrich assumed total power over German newspapers.
As Press Chief, Dietrich assumed total power over German newspapers.
Hans Fritzsche
Nazi Party Press Chief (1931-1945), Vice-President of the Reich
Press Chamber (1933-1945), and Reich Press Chief (1937-1945)
Hans Fritzsche served as head of the German Press Division from 1938–1942. From that position, he issued guidance to the German press editors regarding the themes – including, at times, the so-called “Jewish Problem” – they should address.
Later, he became the head of the German Radio Division, a position he held throughout the war. He hosted a daily radio program “Hans Fritzche Speaks”, which often featured anti-Semitic propaganda.
…he issued guidance to the German press editors regarding the themes – including, at times, the so-called “Jewish Problem” – they should address.